Cheat Bots in Colonist

Cheat Bots in Colonist

Hey everyone, this is Andrew from Colonist.

Over the past few months, some of you have reported bots playing against real people on Colonist. We want to talk about it openly. Here is what we found and what we are doing.

TL;DR

  • We know bots have been playing against real players on Colonist. That’s cheating, and we ban for it
  • 52 bot accounts banned so far, 120+ suspicious accounts reviewed
  • From Oct 2 to Nov 15, bot accounts played ~60,000 games against ~16,000 real players
  • We're building a system that finds bots automatically
  • Games between people must stay games between people
  • We're also making stronger bots you can choose to play

What we found

We’ve seen bot attacks on our players: bots, scripts, and extensions playing against real people

They were run by enthusiasts, companies, and some of our competitors. Some of the parties also scraped your replays to train their bots. Some promoted their bots results publicly. We also saw bot accounts spamming in games to promote AI slop websites.

We’ve read every report you sent us and kept full records of what happened.
From October 2 to November 15, 2026:

  • Bots played about 60,000 games against 16,000 real players
  • That is 1% of all games played between real players in those six weeks
  • We received 24 bot reports on our feedback board in the same period

A small share of games, still too many.

Where we stand: “Games between people must stay between people”

We call this an attack on our players, because that’s what it is.

Every one of those games had a real person who came to play people and got a bot. That cost them the game and their time

This isn’t just someone exploring our platform or running an experiment. Building bot and running it against people who never agreed to play one is cheating. Whether it’s a browser extension, a bot account, or a bot built in a Catan AI community, the rule is the same.

Colonist has never supported cheating and never will

What have we done?

  • 52 bot accounts banned so far
  • We reviewed 120+ suspicious accounts
  • We check player feedback regularly (Discord, suggestion board and in-game reports)
  • You can now report a player as a “Bot / AI player” from the in-game report menu

At the same time, we’ve been studying how they behave and the patterns they leave behind.

What’s next?

Everything we’ve learned is going into a system that finds bots on its own, without waiting for your reports

When it works the way it should:

  • Bots get caught faster, not after weeks
  • Scrapers get blocked before they can copy game replays
  • In-game reports become a backup, not our main defense

We can’t share how it works. Every detail we publish helps the people we’re trying to stop.

It won’t be perfect on day one. People will try to get around it, and we’ll keep adapting. We’ll share how many bots it caught and how many games it protected, so you can judge it yourself.

What about better bots?

We know many of you want to play against stronger bots, and until now Colonist hasn’t offered that.

Our bots were built before the AI era. You’ve asked us to make them harder, add difficulty levels, and turn them into a real challenge you can learn from and use to become a better player.

We’re working on it.

When our new bots are ready, they’ll be done properly: well-designed, thoughtful bots built for our players. Not AI slop, and not bots built to farm attention on social media

How to report

If you think you’ve played against a bot, please report it as a "Bot / AI player" in-game

Thanks for playing fair 🙏